← Open Ledger

Week 4

of 12 ·

Saturday 31 October 2026

My first reply was a no

What I tried

Last week I promised the 3rd pitch, from a list I’d checked

What came back

A kind no from The Unretirees

Pitches sent

1 (running: 3 of 12)

Money in

$0 (running: $0)

Last week I promised the third pitch, from a list I’d checked first. This week I sent it.

But first, I got my first reply. On Saturday, Matt and Dawn from The Unretirees wrote back. They said no. Their channel is booked through the end of 2027, so it isn’t a fit. They also called this a great project and said they’re cheering me on.

I’ll take it. It’s the first time anyone I’ve pitched has written back, and they were kind about it. I sent them a short thank-you. The lesson is one I hadn’t thought about: some shows plan more than a year ahead. Before I pitch, I’ll look at how far out a show books, not only whether it’s still running.

On Wednesday I used the advice from last week’s Reddit replies. One person told me most podcasts list the host’s email in their RSS feed, the file podcast apps read. So I stopped looking for contact forms and opened the feeds instead. In one afternoon I found three shows with ordinary retirees as guests and a way to reach each host directly.

I checked that each one is still running, too. The first venue I picked, a newsletter called RARE Workforce, hasn’t posted a new issue since May. I set it aside.

Pitch 3 went to Colin Messenger, who hosts The Encore Years in the UK. It has a guest every episode, and the latest came out two days before I wrote. I sent it to the email in his feed, not a form.
The same feed trick turned up the real email for Nigel at Wisepreneurs, my first pitch. So I sent him one short follow-up. It went out 22 days after the pitch, which is later than the 7 to 10 days I was told is right. I mentioned his newest episode and said it was the only follow-up I’d send.

I also posted my fifth Reddit update in r/buildinpublic. I thanked the three people who replied last time, showed what I changed because of them, and asked one question: do you ever pitch again after a no?

160 people saw it, and six replied. Two of those replies were ads in disguise. Each opened with some real advice, then got to the product. One sold a service that posts on Reddit for you. The other sold an AI tool that runs your social media.

The rest answered my question, and they didn’t agree. Two said a no with a reason is really about timing. The Unretirees told me exactly when they’re booked through, so I could pitch them again closer to that date. One added that by then they won’t remember me, so the new pitch has to stand on its own. Another said a no is a no.

One person pushed back on me, and fairly. I’d changed my follow-up plan because three strangers told me to, which is the same mistake as reading anything into two pitches. They said the RSS tip was the only advice I could check for myself. They’re right. I checked it, and it worked. Whether a follow-up at 7 to 10 days works better than one at 30, I don’t know yet.

Outside the pitches, I set up a Facebook Page called Only 1 Link, just for OLSP, the program I’m an affiliate for. Facebook refused my first review post there because it had a link in it and I already had a post with a link. So the post went up without the link. Facebook doesn’t like sending people away from Facebook, and I’m learning to work with that instead of against it.

I have always been a strong advocate of “Learn the rules and use them to your advantage.”

Here’s what came back, as of Friday. A kind no from The Unretirees. No reply from Nigel or Colin yet. No confirmed sign-ups. No money.One more email did come in, and I hadn’t asked for it.

Tim, who runs a site called PostYourStartup.co, saw my Reddit post and called it “refreshingly honest.” Then he invited me to list bobcaine.com in his weekly Startup Battle, where visitors vote and the winners get badges. So, counting the two Reddit ads, three of the strangers who wrote to me this week were selling something. I’m not listing. The people who vote on startup sites are founders, not retirees looking for a little extra income, and a Product of the Week badge wouldn’t mean much to the readers I’m trying to reach.

So week 4 reads: one pitch, one follow-up, one Reddit post, $0. The running total is three pitches, five posts, $0.

Next week I’ll pitch the second show on my list, and I’ll check how far ahead it books before I write.

Want it as it happens?

Retire & RISE goes out three times a week, for people over 50 who want to earn something online. One of the three is this record: I'm trying to get somebody to pay me for a skill I already have, and I'm writing down what happens, including the parts that don't work. It starts with me finding out that my 3,456 subscribers weren't real.

Free. Unsubscribe whenever — the link is at the bottom of every email and it works.

All entries: Open Ledger